Showing posts with label Awards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Awards. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

Best Books 2007

Here's a link to the School Library Journal's Best Books 2007.

I think some of the same questions we asked about awards might pertain to these types of lists:

  • What do people notice about the books as a set? In what ways are the books "diverse"? Or, whose stories are being told? In what genres? By whom?
  • How was this list constructed? How are these lists helpful? What are the limitations of such lists?
  • Anyone find a book that they think they otherwise would have missed? Any favorites that are missing from the list?

Tuesday, October 2, 2007

Session 7: Awards assignment

The co-themes of session 7 will be "practicing close readings of text" and analyzing awards for diverse literature. You'll only need to prepare for the second!

Everyone:
  • Read the Aronson and Pinkney articles. What are the arguments for and against honoring books in specific cultural/social categories? What assumptions does each position rely on?
  • Where do you stand in terms of the debate?
Award jigsaw: Research the following information for your assigned award.
  • Is there an official website for the award? Are there other resources that provide information about the award? (Sometimes libraries or author blogs feature information not available on the official sites.)
  • Why and when was this award created? What is the rationale for the award?
  • Selection criteria: What books, authors, illustrators are eligible? How are the books judged?
  • Who sponsors the award?
  • Selection committee: Who chooses the winners? How do you get on the committee? How transparent is the process?
  • Bring in books that have won or have been honored by the award. This will mean a trip to the library--you can coordinate this within your group. How easy was it to find the books? Do they have seals or other indications that they are award winners?
  • It would be helpful if one person in the group could bring in a computer.
In class we'll teach each other about the awards, share books, and talk about the questions that our research raises. The "product" of your group work will be a collaborative post on your award. (Although you'll have time to work on this with your group, most of your research should be done in advance of class.)